Rev. Bernard O’Kavanagh 1848-1852
Rev. Patrick Cuddihy 1852-1857
Rev. Edward Purcell 1857-1891
Rev. Terrence Smith 1891-1900
Rev. James Boyle 1900-1913
R. Rev. Msgr. Bernard Conaty, VG 1913-1940
Rev. Charles Foley 1940-1963
Rev. Thomas Curran 1963-1970
Rev. Msgr. Paul Riedl 1970-1990
Rev. David Farland 1990-1993
Rev. Msgr. Michael Shershanovich 1993-Present